Colgate

FCS

Patriot · Hamilton (NY), Syracuse, New York

370-321-42

All-time

0.505

Win %

National titles

Conf titles

Major bowls

Playoff apps

Weeks at #1

Heismans

Greatest games

Colgate's top games of all time by Game Score.

Sort by

Colgate 9-17 #19 Rutgers

Giants Stadium, New York, New Jersey

1976 · Nov 18, 1976

0.66

Game Score

Colgate 7-7 Dartmouth

Dartmouth

1919 · Nov 1, 1919

0.66

Game Score

Colgate 3-7 Yale

Yale Bowl, New Haven, Connecticut

1916 · Nov 4, 1916

0.64

Game Score

Colgate 6-7 Brown

Brown

1917 · Oct 27, 1917

0.64

Game Score

Colgate 13-13 Yale

Yale Bowl, New Haven, Connecticut

1954 · Oct 23, 1954

0.64

Game Score

Colgate 10-10 Brown

Brown

1926 · Nov 27, 1926

0.60

Game Score

Colgate 0-0 Brown

Brown

1910 · Oct 8, 1910

0.59

Game Score

Colgate 23-23 Ohio State

Ohio Stadium, Columbus, Ohio

1923 · Oct 13, 1923

0.58

Game Score

Colgate 21-0 Brown

Brown

1932 · Nov 19, 1932

0.58

Game Score

Colgate 7-12 Vanderbilt

Dudley Field, Nashville, Tennessee

1928 · Oct 6, 1928

0.56

Game Score

#			Match
1	Nov 18, 1976	1976	Colgate 9-17 #19 Rutgers Giants Stadium, New York, New Jersey	game score 0.66
2	Nov 1, 1919	1919	Colgate 7-7 Dartmouth Dartmouth	game score 0.66
3	Nov 4, 1916	1916	Colgate 3-7 Yale Yale Bowl, New Haven, Connecticut	game score 0.64
4	Oct 27, 1917	1917	Colgate 6-7 Brown Brown	game score 0.64
5	Oct 23, 1954	1954	Colgate 13-13 Yale Yale Bowl, New Haven, Connecticut	game score 0.64
6	Nov 27, 1926	1926	Colgate 10-10 Brown Brown	game score 0.60
7	Oct 8, 1910	1910	Colgate 0-0 Brown Brown	game score 0.59
8	Oct 13, 1923	1923	Colgate 23-23 Ohio State Ohio Stadium, Columbus, Ohio	game score 0.58
9	Nov 19, 1932	1932	Colgate 21-0 Brown Brown	game score 0.58
10	Oct 6, 1928	1928	Colgate 7-12 Vanderbilt Dudley Field, Nashville, Tennessee	game score 0.56

Season by season

Covers NCAA major, I-AA/FCS and their NCAA precursors (College Division 1962-72, Division II 1973-77) only. NAIA, Division III and club seasons are not included.

Lower-level seasons: 45 (264-227-2). The record, titles and bowls above count major seasons only.

2026I-AA / FCSIn progress-

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

—

Conf champ

—

2025I-AA / FCS5-7

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-4

Conf champ

—

2024I-AA / FCS2-10

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

1-5

Conf champ

—

2023I-AA / FCS6-5

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

4-2

Conf champ

—

2022I-AA / FCS3-8

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

2-4

Conf champ

—

2021I-AA / FCS5-6

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

5-1

Conf champ

—

2020I-AA / FCS0-2

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

0-2

Conf champ

—

2019I-AA / FCS4-8

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-3

Conf champ

—

2018I-AA / FCS10-2

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

6-0

Conf champ

★

Notes

FCS quarterfinal

2017I-AA / FCS7-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

5-1

Conf champ

—

2016I-AA / FCS5-5

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

4-2

Conf champ

—

2015I-AA / FCS9-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

6-0

Conf champ

★

Notes

FCS quarterfinal

2014I-AA / FCS5-7

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-3

Conf champ

—

2013I-AA / FCS4-8

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-2

Conf champ

—

2012I-AA / FCS8-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

5-0

Conf champ

★

Notes

FCS playoff

2011I-AA / FCS5-6

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

2-4

Conf champ

—

2010I-AA / FCS7-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-2

Conf champ

—

2009I-AA / FCS9-2

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

4-2

Conf champ

—

2008I-AA / FCS9-3

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

5-0

Conf champ

★

Notes

FCS playoff

2007I-AA / FCS7-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

4-2

Conf champ

—

2006I-AA / FCS4-7

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-3

Conf champ

—

2005I-AA / FCS8-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

5-1

Conf champ

★

Notes

FCS playoff

2004I-AA / FCS7-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

4-2

Conf champ

—

2003I-AA / FCS15-1

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

7-0

Conf champ

★

Notes

FCS title game

2002I-AA / FCS9-3

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

6-1

Conf champ

★

2001I-AA / FCS7-3

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

5-1

Conf champ

—

2000I-AA / FCS7-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

4-2

Conf champ

—

1999I-AA / FCS10-2

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

5-1

Conf champ

★

Notes

FCS playoff

1998I-AA / FCS8-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

5-1

Conf champ

—

Notes

FCS playoff

1997I-AA / FCS7-5

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

6-0

Conf champ

★

Notes

FCS playoff

1996I-AA / FCS6-5

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-2

Conf champ

—

1995I-AA / FCS0-11

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

0-5

Conf champ

—

1994I-AA / FCS3-8

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

2-3

Conf champ

—

1993I-AA / FCS3-7-1

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

1-3

Conf champ

—

1992I-AA / FCS4-7

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

2-3

Conf champ

—

1991I-AA / FCS4-7

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-2

Conf champ

—

1990I-AA / FCS7-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

3-2

Conf champ

—

1989I-AA / FCS4-7

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

1-3

Conf champ

—

1988I-AA / FCS2-9

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

2-3

Conf champ

—

1987I-AA / FCS7-4

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

2-2

Conf champ

—

1986I-AA / FCS4-7

Colgate · Patriot

Conf record

1-3

Conf champ

—

1985I-AA / FCS7-3-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

Conf champ

—

1984I-AA / FCS5-5

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

Conf champ

—

1983I-AA / FCS8-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

Conf champ

—

Notes

FCS playoff

1982I-AA / FCS8-4

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

Conf champ

—

Notes

FCS quarterfinal

1981Major7-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1980Major5-4-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1979Major5-4-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1978Major3-8

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1977Major10-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

#20

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1976Major8-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1975Major6-4

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1974Major4-6

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1973Major5-5

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1972Major5-4-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1971Major6-4

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1970Major5-6

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1969Major5-3-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1968Major5-5

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1967Major2-8

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1966Major8-1-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1965Major6-3-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1964Major7-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1963Major3-4-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1962Major3-5-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1961Major5-4

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1960Major2-7

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1959Major2-7

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1958Major1-8

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1957Major3-6

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1956Major4-5

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1955Major6-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1954Major5-2-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1953Major3-4-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1952Major6-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1951Major4-5

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1950Major5-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1949Major1-8

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1948Major3-6

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1947Major1-5-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1946Major4-4

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1945Major3-4-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1944Major2-5

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1943Major5-3-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1942Major6-2-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1941Major3-3-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1940Major5-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1939Major2-5-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1938Major2-5

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1937Major3-5

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1936Major6-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1935Major5-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1934Major7-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1933Major6-1-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1932Major9-0

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1931Major8-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1930Major9-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1929Major8-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1928Major6-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1927Major4-2-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1926Major5-2-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1925Major7-0-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1924Major5-4

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1923Major6-2-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1922Major6-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1921Major4-4-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1920Major1-5-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1919Major5-1-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1917Major4-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1916Major8-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1915Major5-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1914Major5-2-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1913Major6-1-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1912Major5-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1911Major3-6

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1910Major4-2-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1909Major5-2-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1908Major4-3

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1907Major4-4-1

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1906Major4-2-2

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

1905Major5-4

Colgate · Independent

Conf record

—

AP final

—

Coach final

—

AP high

—

Champ game

—

Conf champ

—

Year	Level	School	Record	Conference	Conf	Conf Champ	High	Bowl / notes
2026In progress	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	-	Patriot
2025	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	5-7	Patriot	3-4
2024	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	2-10	Patriot	1-5
2023	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	6-5	Patriot	4-2
2022	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	3-8	Patriot	2-4
2021	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	5-6	Patriot	5-1
2020	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	0-2	Patriot	0-2
2019	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	4-8	Patriot	3-3
2018	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	10-2	Patriot	6-0	★		FCS quarterfinal
2017	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-4	Patriot	5-1
2016	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	5-5	Patriot	4-2
2015	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	9-4	Patriot	6-0	★		FCS quarterfinal
2014	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	5-7	Patriot	3-3
2013	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	4-8	Patriot	3-2
2012	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	8-4	Patriot	5-0	★		FCS playoff
2011	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	5-6	Patriot	2-4
2010	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-4	Patriot	3-2
2009	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	9-2	Patriot	4-2
2008	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	9-3	Patriot	5-0	★		FCS playoff
2007	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-4	Patriot	4-2
2006	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	4-7	Patriot	3-3
2005	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	8-4	Patriot	5-1	★		FCS playoff
2004	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-4	Patriot	4-2
2003	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	15-1	Patriot	7-0	★		FCS title game
2002	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	9-3	Patriot	6-1	★
2001	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-3	Patriot	5-1
2000	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-4	Patriot	4-2
1999	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	10-2	Patriot	5-1	★		FCS playoff
1998	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	8-4	Patriot	5-1			FCS playoff
1997	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-5	Patriot	6-0	★		FCS playoff
1996	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	6-5	Patriot	3-2
1995	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	0-11	Patriot	0-5
1994	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	3-8	Patriot	2-3
1993	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	3-7-1	Patriot	1-3
1992	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	4-7	Patriot	2-3
1991	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	4-7	Patriot	3-2
1990	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-4	Patriot	3-2
1989	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	4-7	Patriot	1-3
1988	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	2-9	Patriot	2-3
1987	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-4	Patriot	2-2
1986	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	4-7	Patriot	1-3
1985	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	7-3-1	Independent
1984	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	5-5	Independent
1983	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	8-3	Independent				FCS playoff
1982	I-AA / FCS	Colgate	8-4	Independent				FCS quarterfinal
1981	Major	Colgate	7-3	Independent
1980	Major	Colgate	5-4-1	Independent
1979	Major	Colgate	5-4-1	Independent
1978	Major	Colgate	3-8	Independent
1977	Major	Colgate	10-1	Independent			#20
1976	Major	Colgate	8-2	Independent
1975	Major	Colgate	6-4	Independent
1974	Major	Colgate	4-6	Independent
1973	Major	Colgate	5-5	Independent
1972	Major	Colgate	5-4-1	Independent
1971	Major	Colgate	6-4	Independent
1970	Major	Colgate	5-6	Independent
1969	Major	Colgate	5-3-1	Independent
1968	Major	Colgate	5-5	Independent
1967	Major	Colgate	2-8	Independent
1966	Major	Colgate	8-1-1	Independent
1965	Major	Colgate	6-3-1	Independent
1964	Major	Colgate	7-2	Independent
1963	Major	Colgate	3-4-1	Independent
1962	Major	Colgate	3-5-1	Independent
1961	Major	Colgate	5-4	Independent
1960	Major	Colgate	2-7	Independent
1959	Major	Colgate	2-7	Independent
1958	Major	Colgate	1-8	Independent
1957	Major	Colgate	3-6	Independent
1956	Major	Colgate	4-5	Independent
1955	Major	Colgate	6-3	Independent
1954	Major	Colgate	5-2-2	Independent
1953	Major	Colgate	3-4-2	Independent
1952	Major	Colgate	6-3	Independent
1951	Major	Colgate	4-5	Independent
1950	Major	Colgate	5-3	Independent
1949	Major	Colgate	1-8	Independent
1948	Major	Colgate	3-6	Independent
1947	Major	Colgate	1-5-2	Independent
1946	Major	Colgate	4-4	Independent
1945	Major	Colgate	3-4-1	Independent
1944	Major	Colgate	2-5	Independent
1943	Major	Colgate	5-3-1	Independent
1942	Major	Colgate	6-2-1	Independent			#9
1941	Major	Colgate	3-3-2	Independent
1940	Major	Colgate	5-3	Independent
1939	Major	Colgate	2-5-1	Independent
1938	Major	Colgate	2-5	Independent
1937	Major	Colgate	3-5	Independent
1936	Major	Colgate	6-3	Independent
1935	Major	Colgate	5-3	Independent
1934	Major	Colgate	7-1	Independent
1933	Major	Colgate	6-1-1	Independent
1932	Major	Colgate	9-0	Independent
1931	Major	Colgate	8-1	Independent
1930	Major	Colgate	9-1	Independent
1929	Major	Colgate	8-1	Independent
1928	Major	Colgate	6-3	Independent
1927	Major	Colgate	4-2-3	Independent
1926	Major	Colgate	5-2-2	Independent
1925	Major	Colgate	7-0-2	Independent
1924	Major	Colgate	5-4	Independent
1923	Major	Colgate	6-2-1	Independent
1922	Major	Colgate	6-3	Independent
1921	Major	Colgate	4-4-2	Independent
1920	Major	Colgate	1-5-2	Independent
1919	Major	Colgate	5-1-1	Independent
1917	Major	Colgate	4-2	Independent
1916	Major	Colgate	8-1	Independent
1915	Major	Colgate	5-1	Independent
1914	Major	Colgate	5-2-1	Independent
1913	Major	Colgate	6-1-1	Independent
1912	Major	Colgate	5-2	Independent
1911	Major	Colgate	3-6	Independent
1910	Major	Colgate	4-2-1	Independent
1909	Major	Colgate	5-2-1	Independent
1908	Major	Colgate	4-3	Independent
1907	Major	Colgate	4-4-1	Independent
1906	Major	Colgate	4-2-2	Independent
1905	Major	Colgate	5-4	Independent

Award winners

6 major award winners and consensus All-Americans.

Leonard Macaluso1930

Consensus All-AmericanB

D. Belford West1919

Consensus All-AmericanT

Clarence Horning1916

Consensus All-AmericanT

D. Belford West1916

Consensus All-AmericanT

Oscar Anderson1916

Consensus All-AmericanB

Ellery Huntington1913

Consensus All-AmericanB

Year	Player	Pos	Award
1930	Leonard Macaluso	B	Consensus All-American
1919	D. Belford West	T	Consensus All-American
1916	Clarence Horning	T	Consensus All-American
1916	D. Belford West	T	Consensus All-American
1916	Oscar Anderson	B	Consensus All-American
1913	Ellery Huntington	B	Consensus All-American